Minor Offenders, Major Offenses: A series by The Daily Memphian


In this series, The Daily Memphian’s team of reporters dives deep into the pressing issue of juvenile crime. 

Introduction to “Minor Offenders, Major Offenses” 

Metro editor Jane Donahoe offers an overview of stories in the series, explaining that the issue of juvenile crime is “complex and uncomfortable, with outsize effects on the city, its citizens and its very future.”

No ‘more pressing’ issue in Memphis community than juvenile crime 

In the 1980s, juvenile offenses were mostly crimes like shoplifting, petty theft and auto thefts. Now, children currently held in detention are accused of first-degree murder, second-degree murder, carjacking, rape of a child and other crimes.

‘Trying to survive:’ Chronic absenteeism, more than truancy, concerning to local educators

Criminalizing students for frequently missing school can actually make things worse: “You label a kid as delinquent, you actually create a future criminal.” 

‘The kids that did this to us’: Juveniles driving car crimes higher 

A large part of the area’s current juvenile crime issue centers on car thefts and thefts of property from vehicles.

Juvenile Justice

Here’s how Tennessee lawmakers plan to target juvenile justice this session

In this installment of “Minor Offenders, Major Offenses,” we look at how lawmakers intend to build on the mandatory-minimum “truth in sentencing” law with bills that treat juveniles as adults in more circumstances. Many of the tough-on-crime proposals pivot from former Gov. Bill Haslam’s moderate juvenile justice reform effort in 2018. 

‘Not in the best condition': Tennessee looks to replace youth detention center

The Daily Memphian takes a look at Tennessee’s only state-run, hardware-secure juvenile detention facility currently in use. Wilder Youth Development Center opened in 1971, and various officials say it needs to either be replaced or expanded. 

Juvenile Court

A primer: How Shelby County Juvenile Court works

In this story, we answer some of the basic questions about Juvenile Court and its responsibilities. Despite it being a court of record, “there is little standardization in juvenile court size, case management procedures and court administrative practices” across the state. 

When the Justice Department came for Shelby County Juvenile Court

Much of the current framework of the Memphis and Shelby County Juvenile Court is the result of a 2012 agreement between Shelby County elected leaders and the Civil Rights Division of the U.S. Justice Department.

“Sometimes we walk out of there scratching our heads because we don’t have all the answers, and all answers don’t rest within the Memphis Police Department,” Davis said.

— MPD Chief Cerelyn Davis

Officials work to increase juvenile transparency amid tight state laws

The limited access to juvenile court proceedings and case records may change as local leaders push for publicly available data and other case records. 

Solutions

‘It’s not going to go away unless we do something:' Local leaders eye juvenile crime solutions

In Memphis, leaders seem to agree that youth are able to get guns too easily and that they are seeing a trend of younger juvenile offenders and more violent offenses. But there are varying opinions on how to deal with those trends.

Advocate knows change is possible in Juvenile Court because she’s seen it

Stephanie Hill, a “fierce” advocate for children and youth, sees the best in the children she works with and also believes it is our responsibility to do what we can to give them opportunities to succeed. 

“Minor Offenders, Major Offenses” Sources

The Daily Memphian’s reporting team interviewed 37 individuals as sources for this series.

Alexa Bambrick, carjacking victim

Floyd Bonner Jr., Shelby County Sheriff 

Jake Brown, Memphis attorney

Alex Canale, attempted carjacking victim

Stephen Chandler, Memphis Police Department deputy chief of special operations

Buddy Chapman, CrimeStoppers executive director

Cerelyn “C.J.” Davis, Memphis Police Department chief 

Jack Derryberry, Disability Rights Tennessee’s legal director

Alex Denis, spokeswoman for the Department of Children’s Services

Lesley Dumas, Memphis Allies

Bill Gibbons, executive director of the Public Safety Institute at The University of Memphis

Greg Glod, senior policy fellow for criminal justice at Americans for Prosperity

Molly Gormley, spokeswoman for the Senate Republican Caucus

Mary Hamlett, vice president of family programs at MIFA

Lee Harris, Shelby County Mayor

Rep. Torrey Harris (D-Memphis), state representative

Stephanie Hill, deputy chief administrative officer and chief of strategy and innovation

Alice Marie Johnson, a Memphis criminal justice reform activist

Lt. Gov. Randy McNally (R-Oak Ridge), state senator

Dan Michael, former Shelby County Juvenile Court Judge

Steve Mulroy, Shelby County District Attorney General 

Garrett O’Brien, former MPD Auto Theft Task Force officer

Linda O’Neal, former director of Tennessee Commission on Children and Youth

Ugur Orak, assistant professor at Middle Tennessee State University

Shawn Page, Memphis-Shelby County Schools chief of academic operations and school support

Rob Philyaw, Hamilton County Juvenile Court Judge 

Rory Pulvino, director of analytics for Justice Innovation Labs

Dean Rivkin, professor emeritus of law at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville

Cameron Sexton (R-Crossville), state representative and house speaker 

Josh Spickler, executive director of Just City

Jim Strickland, Memphis Mayor 

Tarik Sugarmon, Shelby County Juvenile Court Judge

Cara Suvall, Vanderbilt Law School assistant clinical professor of law

Sen. Page Walley (R-Savannah), state senator

Jennifer Wade, court administrator for Juvenile Court of Metropolitan Nashville and Davidson County

Alicia Washington, Shelby County District Attorney General Office’s chief juvenile prosecutor

Stephanie White, executive director of media for Shelby County Juvenile Court