When? Why? Is this double jeopardy? Questions arise in new trial for former officers
News broke last week that three of the former Memphis police officers convicted federally in the 2023 death of Tyré Nichols are getting a new trial.
A chain of events that eventually led to Tadarrius Bean, Demetrius Haley and Justin Smith being granted the new trial centers on comments allegedly made by U.S. District Judge Mark Norris who presided over the case from its inception in 2023 until his abrupt recusal in June 2025. Also at issue is the attempted murder of one of Norris’ former law clerks, a crime the judge wanted investigated as a federal matter because he allegedly did not trust MPD.
This is an excerpt of this story. To read more, please click here and subscribe.
Topics
Subscriber Only Tyré Nichols U.S. District Judge Mark NorrisThank you for reading The Daily Memphian. Your support is critical.
Did you know we are a 501(c)3 nonprofit news organization? We rely on a mix of revenue from subscriptions (50%), advertising, events and other earned income (25%) and fundraising (25%).
Please consider making a fully tax-deductible donation or other contribution to The Daily Memphian today.
👉🏽 Your subscription pays for you to read all our journalism.
👉🏽 Your donation powers the work we do to reach everyone else with the news.
We believe an informed Memphis is a better Memphis. If you agree, join our growing list of donors now.
Aarron Fleming
Once an intern, he never left, joining the staff full-time in 2022 as an education reporter. He moved to public safety in 2023, where he covered some of the city’s biggest court cases, including the criminal trials for those charged in the deaths of Tyré Nichols and rapper Young Dolph. He also chronicled the Shelby County Jail and the deaths that have occurred at the facility.
He now provides suburban coverage, focusing on DeSoto County and the surrounding municipalities.
Public Safety on demand
Sign up to receive Public Safety stories as they’re published.
Enter your e-mail address
Comments
Want to comment on our stories? If you’re a subscriber, scroll down to the comments. If you’re not a subscriber, only paid subscribers can add their thoughts, so subscribe now. Our commenting policy can be viewed here.