Premium

Memphians mourn old Mellow Mushroom building targeted for demo

By , Daily Memphian Updated: November 18, 2024 4:00 AM CT | Published: November 18, 2024 4:00 AM CT

Sherry Greene, born and raised in Memphis, was 10 when the circular, stone-stacked building at the corner of South White Station Road and Park Avenue was built in 1965.

She remembered her father, a contractor, talking about the unique rounded building being built for Union Planters Bank at 5138 Park Ave.

For Greene and many others, the building became a landmark. 


Demolition of Carrefour at Kirby Woods moved up as last tenants plan to go


Sixty years later, the mid-century modern building will be demolished to make way for a 3,000-square-foot Bojangles. 

The 9,989-square-foot building, last occupied by Mellow Mushroom, has sat vacant on the market for the past year, still fitted with the restaurant’s wall-to-wall murals and mushroom mascot outside. 

Lifelong Memphian Katie Mars moved from the University of Memphis two years ago into a neighborhood near the former Mellow Mushroom and was a frequent customer before it closed. She said the unique space matched Mellow Mushroom, which frequently occupies unconventional spaces.

“The inside has really cool windows, and when you look up, it is almost like what you would see in a cathedral,” Mars said. “The ceiling was a really cool feature that had all these beams connected down to the pillars on the outside of the building.” 

Located on less than an acre at the Eastgate Shopping Center, the property is being marketed by The Shopping Center Group. 


UTHSC has plans for new $350M building


Mars said she understood that the building’s large size and odd shape could make finding a tenant difficult, resulting in a demolition and build-to-suit option more appealing.

“It’s really sad to see a building that has a lot of history, especially in East Memphis, when there’s not a ton of those left, be demolished for a fast food restaurant that’s probably going to make traffic a bit of a nightmare,” Mars said. 

Some residents turned to the Memphis Heritage Association for help saving the property. However, the association cannot legally intervene in privately owned buildings. 

Topics

Mellow Mushroom 5138 Park Ave. AAA Union Planters Bank TSCG Sea Isle Park Eastgate Shopping Center Subscriber Only

Thank you for supporting local journalism.

Subscribers to The Daily Memphian help fund our not-for-profit newsroom of nearly 40 local journalists plus more than 20 freelancers, all of whom work around the clock to cover the issues impacting our community. Subscriptions - and donations - also help fund our community access programs which provide free access to K-12 schools, community organizations, and more. Thank you for making our work possible.

Sophia Surrett

Sophia Surrett

Sophia Surrett is a recent University of Alabama graduate, where she received her B.A. in news media and M.A. in journalism and media studies. She covers restaurants, residential real estate, and hospitality and tourism.


Comments

Want to comment on our stories or respond to others? Join the conversation by subscribing now. Only paid subscribers can add their thoughts or upvote/downvote comments. Our commenting policy can be viewed here