Turkey every day: Eight Memphis ways to eat Thanksgiving bird year-round
Let’s talk turkey.
It’s the traditional Thanksgiving centerpiece that some (too many!) lament. For the other 364 days a year, turkey most often appears, if at all, as the foundation for strictly utilitarian cold-cut sandwiches or in smoked-leg form as a fair and festival novelty.
You certainly won’t find turkey jockeying with chicken — much less steak, fish, pork or duck — on the dinner menus of “fine dining” restaurants.
But there’s more than that to this taken-for-granted gobbler. And turkey seems to get in the game more often at both barbecue and soul-food restaurants, and perhaps that makes Memphis a pretty good turkey town.
Whether turkey will grace your Thanksgiving table next week or not, here are eight year-round Memphis recommendations for consuming this too-maligned bird.
Pulled-turkey sandwich at BallHoggerz BBQ
Pulled-turkey sandwich served at BallHoggerz BBQ. (Joshua Carlucci/Special to The Daily Memphian)
In an episode of “Sound Bites” earlier this year, I told Chris we should give turkey its flowers after eating a pulled turkey sandwich from Orange Mound’s BallHoggerz BBQ, located at 1404 Airways Blvd. This was my first barbecue turkey experience in Memphis and it still holds a dear place in my heart.
It’s rare to see a turkey treated with as much care as pork. Merritt Bailey, the pitmaster-mind behind BallHoggerz, is doing just that.
Less than $10 will get you a massive sandwich loaded with pulled smoked turkey leg, sparkling with Bailey’s spice blend and pickles, as well as two sides. And this turkey is as moist, smoky and flavorful as its porcine counterpart. – Joshua Carlucci
Turkey and dressing at the Four Way Soul Food Restaurant
Turkey and dressing served at the Four Way. (Chris Herrington/The Daily Memphian)
There are people who think turkey and dressing is only Thanksgiving food, and there are people who eat at South Memphis’ Four Way Soul Food Restaurant (998 Mississippi Blvd.), a Soulsville staple since 1946.
The Four Way is arguably the signature soul food restaurant in Memphis, and deservedly so for its combination of social function in a historic neighborhood and across-the-board quality. And turkey and dressing, an ostensible occasion food, is an everyday menu anchor, seemingly the restaurant’s most popular dish.
The tender roast turkey is chopped, more chunks than shards. The savory cornbread dressing is never dry. Together, they arrive adorned with their own gravy, lighter than the brown gravy you’ll get on the mashed potatoes, and with a little side of cranberry sauce. Our greatest holiday comes but once a year. Except at the Four Way, where you can have a proper Thanksgiving meal year-round, Thursdays through Sundays. – Chris Herrington
Turkey legs at Uncle Red’s
Fries served at Uncle Red's. (Joshua Carlucci/Special to The Daily Memphian)
I’ve had many a turkey leg in my day, and few better than those of Uncle Red’s (formerly Redbone’s), a permanent pop-up inside of Downtown’s Carolina Watershed (141 E. Carolina Ave.).
The menu at Uncle Red’s is almost entirely based on smoked turkey leg meat, which they’ve got down to a science. It’s impossibly fall-off-the-bone tender and can be ordered in the form of salads, fries and bowls.
But I prefer it straight from the source. Uncle Red’s main squeeze is the full, bone-in turkey leg, smothered in whatever sauce or combination of toppings you should choose. Sauces include the likes of Tennessee whiskey glaze and honey gold, and you can pick toppings such as mac and cheese or dirty rice.
Whatever you pick, it’ll likely be the least boring turkey you eat this year. – Carlucci
Turkey necks at Ms. Girlee’s Soul Food
Turkey necks served at Ms. Girlee’s. (Chris Herrington/The Daily Memphian)
In the universe of “meat-and-three” mains found only at soul-food restaurants, turkey necks are forgotten heroes. Not as forbidding as chitterlings or pig feet. Not as romantic-seeming to novices as oxtails, neckbones or ham hocks.
But they function much the same way as oxtails or neckbones, while being considerably more affordable than the former and healthfuller than either. All those little slivers and pockets of meat, packed around bone, get impossibly tender and flavorful when slow-cooked. It is an often-discarded or taken-for-granted cut, does not make an attractive plate and takes a little work, but it is delicious. The essence of soul food.
And so is Ms. Girlee’s Soul Food (629 Chelsea Ave.) writ large. This proud family restaurant is more a bustling North Memphis neighborhood staple than a destination for curiosity-seekers. At peak times, the line past the serving station goes out the back door into the parking lot. It’s a privilege to stand in that line for whatever’s available on a menu that changes daily. Turkey necks are usually available Wednesdays, but every day is a winner. – Herrington
Sliced turkey sandwich at Bain Barbecue
The only Texas-style barbecue restaurant in Memphis, Cooper-Young’s Bain Barbecue (993 Cooper St.) has some of the best smoked meat in town. And though beef brisket is undoubtedly king in Texas, don’t overlook the turkey.
Bain’s turkey sandwich is a Martin’s potato roll layered with thick, shingled slabs of smoked turkey breast, seasoned with the simple salt-and-pepper rub that is characteristic of Texas barbecue.
Available regular- or jumbo-sized, it’s smoky, piney and uncharacteristically moist and delicious for turkey breast. This sandwich is a hit, even for dark-meat lovers like myself. Slather the sandwich with some of Bain’s wonderful barbecue sauce and stuff it with the vinegary pickles and onions that come on the side. – Carlucci
Turkey melt at Restaurant Iris
Turkey melt served at Restaurant Iris. (Chris Herrington/The Daily Memphian)
Where do Louisville, Argentina and New Orleans meet up in Memphis? Confused? Saddle up to the bar at Restaurant Iris (4550 Poplar Ave.), the New Orleans-inspired East Memphis eatery, and order the new turkey melt.
It’s a kind of twist on the Louisville “hot brown,” an open-faced, saucy/cheesy turkey sandwich.
Here, slow-roasted Cajun turkey is tossed in French-onion gravy and poured over toasted brioche with a smear of dijonnaise. How does Argentina figure in? The cheese finisher is provoleta, a grilled Argentinian variation on provolone.
Perhaps relatedly, Iris’ sibling sandwich shop, Fino’s, has lately had a quite good hot Cajun turkey sub special with lettuce, tomato, brown mustard and provolone. – Herrington
Turkey nachos at Central BBQ
Turkey nachos served at Central BBQ. (Joshua Carlucci/Special to The Daily Memphian)
According to local food lore, barbecue nachos are a quintessentially Memphis dish known primarily for their use of pulled pork. Central BBQ (with multiple locations) has the pork, of course, but it also offers its nachos with turkey — a bit of a rarity in town, but just as delicious.
Smoked and sliced pieces of turkey breast dangle over a mountain of chips, drizzled with generous amounts of mild barbecue sauce and nacho cheese and garnished with more (shredded) cheese and jalapeños.
It’s a bit of a mess, but it’s a good one. The sweet and tangy barbecue sauce and rich nacho cheese make an oddly delicious combo and provide adequate chip coverage. The turkey is plenty tender and tasty, and lighter than the fattier pork alternative. One could call this a healthful option, I suppose.
My only complaint is that the chips are a bit too thin to support the heavy toppings, but that’s being picky. – Carlucci
(Herrington note: Consider the Jennifer-Biggs-endorsed adjustment of ordering the nachos with the sturdier house-made potato chips.)
Turkey taco at Elwood’s Shack
The Steelhead trout taco is a signature dish at Elwood’s Shack (4523 Summer Ave. and 4040 Park Ave.), and Elwood’s notion of a “taco” is sort of a genre unto itself: A big flour tortilla, toasted to “crunchy,” with melted white cheese covering most of the surface, holding the protein in place, adorned with pico de gallo, field greens, avocados and horseradish dressing.
If the fish isn’t your thing or you just want to switch it up, the taco works as well, if not better, with the Shack’s house-smoked turkey, sliced thin and layered into the cheese.
Or if you want turkey in more-familiar sandwich form, Elwood’s is a good spot for that, too, with its signature Elwood’s Melt blending the same house-smoked turkey with Black Forest ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato and red-pepper aioli on sourdough. It also offers a turkey Reuben and a simple smoked-turkey sandwich.
Topics
Subscriber Only Turkey RestaurantsAre you enjoying your subscription?
Your subscription gives you unlimited access to all of The Daily Memphian’s news, written by nearly 40 local journalists and more than 20 regular freelancers. We work around the clock to cover the issues that impact your life and our community.
You can help us reach more Memphians.
As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, we provide free news access at K-12 schools, public libraries and many community organizations. We also reach tens of thousands of people through our podcasts, and through our radio and television partnerships – all completely free to everyone who cares about Memphis.
When you subscribe, you get full access to our news. But when you donate, you help us reach all Memphians.
Pay it forward. Make a fully tax-deductible donation to The Daily Memphian today.
Thank you for reading the local news. Thank you for investing in our community.
Chris Herrington on demand
Never miss an article. Sign up to receive Chris Herrington's stories as they’re published.
Enter your e-mail address
Chris Herrington
Chris Herrington has covered the Memphis Grizzlies, in one way or another, since the franchise’s second season in Memphis, while also writing about music, movies, food and civic life. As far as he knows, he’s the only member of the Professional Basketball Writers Association who is also a member of a film critics group and has also voted in national music critic polls for Rolling Stone and the Village Voice (RIP). He and his wife have two kids and, for reasons that sometimes elude him, three dogs.
Joshua Carlucci
Joshua Carlucci is a writer and food journalist from Los Banos, California. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Berkeley, a culinary diploma from the Institute of Culinary Education, and an MFA in Creative Writing from the University of Memphis, where he was managing editor of Pinch. His work has appeared or is forthcoming in The Brussels Review, Redivider, Gravy, EatingWell, Southern Living, and elsewhere. He is a staff writer at Brooklyn-based food and beverage industry magazine, StarChefs.Find more of his work on his website, joshuacarlucci.com.
Want to comment on our stories or respond to others? Join the conversation by subscribing now. Only paid subscribers can add their thoughts or upvote/downvote comments. Our commenting policy can be viewed here.